I've actually had a membership to Dick Dorm in the past, which is why I felt like it deserved a mention on my list of top gay premium sites. What is Dick Dorm, you ask? Well, it's a place where you go to see those horny amateur studs getting up to no good. What we have here is a college-themed hub where real gay twinks or straight boys get together and have a little fun.
I fully recommend you take a look at the tour of this place for a look at what they have to offer. The content is very amateur and clearly produced by some of the freshest names in gay porn. Oh, you can also submit your own material and be in the running for a prize of $10,000. I don't know about you, but that's quite the offer!
The archive here is a little thin with just 50 scenes, but updates do come in from time to time, so it may rise through the ranks in no time at all.