Amateur porn is one niche that I absolutely love exploring, so it was a no-brainer for me to mention Randy Blue. The site has been around for over a dozen years now, and that's because they have consistently provided the gay porn community with some of the best material the Internet has to offer.
Their current archive sits at 1,200 videos and 1,500 photo sets - the former lasting about 20 minutes on average and the latter containing around 70 pictures per update. All of the content here is 100% exclusive to the site and each of the 600 models have their own profiles so you can hone in on the amateur stud that's for you.
Randy Blue updates on a weekly basis with around 3 new scenes. There are no bonus sites to speak of, but with no download limits or DRM restrictions, it's not like you need them in the first place. My advice? Check out the tour for Randy Blue and if you want good quality gay amateur porn, get yourself a membership.